Alan Cumming, the scene-stealing host of Peacock’s hit reality series The Traitors, has never been shy about bringing a touch of wit and theatrical flair to the show. In a recent interview at the 77th Emmy Awards, I asked him a playful question that fans of the series often debate: If you could pick anyone in the entire world to compete on The Traitors, who would it be?
Cumming didn’t hesitate with his answer. His dream casting choice? President Donald Trump.
The response was classic Alan Cumming—sharp, unexpected, and full of humor. Considering the show’s premise of deception, manipulation, and psychological gameplay, Cumming’s choice immediately paints a picture of the kind of chaos, strategy, and high-stakes drama that would dominate the Scottish castle if Trump were ever a contestant.
Cumming’s bold answer not only reflects his mischievous sense of humor, but also highlights how The Traitors has become more than just a reality competition. It’s a stage where personalities—big, small, and larger-than-life—shine under pressure. And imagining someone as polarizing and media-savvy as Donald Trump in that mix? It’s easy to see why Cumming’s answer got such a reaction.
As The Traitors continues to grow its fanbase and dominate the reality TV conversation, Cumming’s off-the-cuff casting suggestion proves just how much fun the show can be when you imagine it beyond the screen.
One thing is certain: if Alan Cumming ever got his wish, it would make for one of the most unforgettable seasons of The Traitors yet.
Watch the response below from Alan Cumming:
